Albert Barnes Commentary Acts 5:38

"And now I say unto you, Refrain from these men, and let them alone: for if this counsel or this work be of men, it will be overthrown:" — Acts 5:38 (ASV)

Refrain from these men. Cease to oppose them, or to threaten them. The reason why he advised this, he immediately adds: that if it were of men, it would come to nothing; if of God, they could not overthrow it.

This counsel. This plan or purpose. If the apostles had originated it for the purposes of imposture,

It will come to nothing. Gamaliel inferred that from the two instances which he specified. They had been suppressed without the interference of the Sanhedrin, and he inferred that this would also die away if it was a human device.

It will be remembered that this is the mere advice of Gamaliel, who was not inspired, and that this opinion should not be cited to guide us, except as it was an instance of great shrewdness and prudence.

It is, doubtless, right to oppose error in the proper way and with the proper temper—not with arms, verbal abuse, or the civil power, but with argument and kind entreaty.

But the sentiment of Gamaliel is full of wisdom in regard to error. For:

1. The very way to exalt error into notice, and to confirm men in it, is to oppose it in a harsh, authoritative, and unkind manner.

2. Error, if left alone, will often die away by itself. The interest of men in it will often cease as soon as it ceases to be opposed; and having nothing to fan the flame, it will expire. It is not so with truth.

3. In this respect, the remark may be applied to the Christian religion. It has stood too long, and in too many circumstances of prosperity and adversity, to be of men. It has been subjected to all trials from its pretended friends and real foes, and it still lives as vigorous and flourishing as ever.

Other kingdoms have changed; empires have risen and fallen since Gamaliel spoke this; systems of opinion and belief have had their day, and expired. But the preservation of the Christian religion, unchanged through so many revolutions, and in so many fiery trials, shows that it is not of men, but of God.

The argument for the Divine origin of the Christian religion from its perpetuity, is one that can be applied to no other system that has been, or that now exists.

For Christianity has been opposed in every form. It confers no temporal conquests, and appeals to no base and strong native passions.

Islam is supported by the sword and the state; paganism relies on the arm of the civil power and the terrors of superstition, and is sustained by all the corrupt passions of men.

Atheism and infidelity have been short-lived, varying in their forms—dying today, and tomorrow starting up in a new form—never organized, consolidated, or pure, and never tending to promote the peace or happiness of men.

Christianity, without arms or human power, has lived, holding its steady and triumphant movements among men, regardless of both the opposition of its foes and the treachery of its pretended friends.

If the opinion of Gamaliel was just, it is from God; and the Jews particularly should regard as important an argument derived from the opinion of one of the wisest of their ancient Rabbis.