Albert Barnes Commentary Hosea 8:6

"For from Israel is even this; the workman made it, and it is no God; yea, the calf of Samaria shall be broken in pieces." — Hosea 8:6 (ASV)

For - This verse may assign the reasons for God’s displeasure, mine anger is kindled; or for Israel’s impenitence, How long will it be? This indeed is only going a little further back, for Israel’s incorrigibility was the ground of God’s displeasure. And they were incorrigible because they had themselves devised it; for from Israel was it also. Those are especially incorrigible who do not fall into error through ignorance, but who through malice devise it from their own heart. Such persons act and speak, not as seduced by others, but seducing themselves, and condemned by their own judgment. Such were Israel and Jeroboam his king, who were not induced or seduced by others to consider the golden calf to be God, but devised it with malicious intent, knowing that it was not God.

Hence, Israel could be cured of the worship of Baal, for this was brought from outside by Jezebel; and Jehu destroyed Baal out of Israel. But they could not be healed of the sin of the calf. In this sin all the kings of Israel were impenitent.

From Israel was it also - Their boast that they were of Israel aggravated their sin. They said to God, “We, Israel, know you.” So then their offense, too, their brutishness also, was from those who boasted of bearing the name of their forefather, Israel, who were the chosen people of God, so distinguished by His favor. The name of Israel, suggesting their close relationship to God, the great things He had done for them, and their solemn covenant with Him to be His people as He was their God, should, in itself, have made them ashamed of such brutishness. So Paul appeals to us by our name as Christians, Let every one who names the Name of Christ depart from iniquity (2 Timothy 2:19).

The workman made it, therefore it is not God - The workman was rather a god to his idol than it was to him, for he made it; it was a thing made. To say that it was made was to deny that it was God. Hence, the prophets so often urge this special proof of the vanity of idols.

No creature can be God. Nor can there be anything between God and a creature: “Every substance which is not God is a creature; and that which is not a creature, is God.” God Himself could not make a creature who should be God.

The Arian heresy, which imagined that God the Son could be a creature and yet an object of our worship, or that there could be a secondary god, was folly as well as blasphemy. They did not conceive what God is. They had low, debased notions of the Godhead. They did not know that the Creator is infinitely far above His most exalted creature, as above the lowest.

Nor do the prophets need any subtleties (such as the pagans alleged) that their idol might be indwelt by some influence. Since God did not dwell in it, any such influence could only come from a creature, and that, an evil one.

The calf of Samaria shall be broken in pieces - The calves were set up at Bethel and Dan, but they were the sort of tutelary deity of the ten tribes; therefore they are called the calf of Samaria. They represented one and the same thing, which is why they are called as one, the calf, not “calves.” It was a worthless thing in its origin, for it had its form and shape from man; it should be a worthless thing in its end, for it should be broken in pieces, or become chips, fragments, for fire.