Charles Ellicott Commentary 1 Peter 2:17

"Honor all men. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honor the king." — 1 Peter 2:17 (ASV)

Honour all men.—“These words present very briefly, yet not obscured by their brevity, but also very plainly, the sum of our duty towards God and men: to men, both in general, honour all men; in special relations—in their Christian or religious relations, love the brotherhood, and in a chief civil relation, honour the king. And our whole duty to God, comprised under the name of His fear, is set in the middle between these, as the common source of all duty to men, of all due observance of it, and the sovereign rule by which it is to be regulated” (Leighton).

Saint Paul had said that this honour was to be paid to those to whom it was due; Saint Peter says that this includes all men. There is not one who can be entirely despised, not one who has quite lost the likeness of Christ; Jews are not at liberty to despise even the idolatrous Gentiles.

Love the brotherhood.—See 1 Peter 5:9, and the note on 1 Peter 1:22. The brotherhood means, of course, all Christians, who (mystically, even now that the Church is divided, but then actually) formed a single fellowship. “All men,” Christian or non-Christian, are to be “honoured,” but there is a special sense in which love is only possible between fellow Christians. For the converse proposition, see Matthew 5:44.

Fear God.—This enforces reverence for every law and ordinance of God, and therefore serves suitably to introduce the next precept. Rebellion against Nero is rebellion against God (Romans 13:2).

Honour the king.—This is the climax. Logically, the preceding commands have only been inserted for the purpose of bringing out this last one more clearly. This was the point on which the Christian religion was assailed, and putting the readers through their catechism (as it were) of duties in other respects awakens their conscience to receive this precept.

1 Peter 2:13–16 have insisted on the duty of political submission, and then the writer steps back, so to speak, for a final thrust: “So—as to all men you must pay reverence; as to the Christians, love; as to God, fear—so to the emperor you must pay constant reverence.” It is hardly right to say with Bengel that this paragraph is specially written because of the usual disaffection of Jews towards the Roman government; rather it is called for (like the warning of 1 Peter 2:11–12), not by any special temptation within them, but by the particular circumstances of the time, that is, the slanders that were circulating against Christians.