Charles Ellicott Commentary 1 Samuel 17:15

"Now David went to and fro from Saul to feed his father`s sheep at Beth-lehem." — 1 Samuel 17:15 (ASV)

Returned from Saul to feed his father’s sheep. —This short statement was undoubtedly introduced by the compiler of the First Book of Samuel to show that, in spite of this apparent introduction of David into the history for the first time in this chapter (see 1 Samuel 17:12 and following), and the inquiry of King Saul from Abner concerning the young hero’s father (see 1 Samuel 17:55–58), he, the compiler, was perfectly aware that David had already visited the court of Saul as a musician (see 1 Samuel 16:18–23). As has already been suggested, these historical books of the Old Testament are undoubtedly made up from contemporary documents, most likely stored in one or another of the prophetic schools.

It is, therefore, to be expected that certain facts will be found occasionally repeated. The circumstances connected with the healing influence of the music of David in the case of the soul malady of King Saul were of course preserved with great care and detail in these “schools,” where music and poetry were so highly cultivated and esteemed. We have here many of the very words of the original narrative preserved for us. Similarly, the story of David’s first exploit is incorporated in the history, probably unchanged. Each of these ancient and favourite “memories” of David, being complete in themselves, would of course contain some of the same details.

The apparent ignorance of Saul and Abner concerning the young shepherd’s family will be discussed in the note on 1 Samuel 17:55–58.