Charles Ellicott Commentary Ezekiel 18:19

"Yet say ye, Wherefore doth not the son bear the iniquity of the father? when the son hath done that which is lawful and right, and hath kept all my statutes, and hath done them, he shall surely live." — Ezekiel 18:19 (ASV)

Why? Does not the son bear? —It would be clearer to read this as a single question, “Why does not the son, etc.?” It is the question proposed by the people in objection to what has been declared. To them it seemed the law of nature, the necessity of the case, the teaching of history, that the son should bear the iniquity of his father. Their ideas had not risen to the conception of man’s individual responsibility to God; to them the individual was still but a part of the nation or the family.

They ask, therefore, why this universal law should now be reversed. It was not true that any law was reversed; it was only that the superior prevailed over the inferior law; but, as usual in such cases, the Divine word does not reason with the human objection, but in this and the following verse only reiterates most emphatically the law of individual responsibility.