Charles Ellicott Commentary Hosea 1:2

"When Jehovah spake at the first by Hosea, Jehovah said unto Hosea, Go, take unto thee a wife of whoredom and children of whoredom; for the land doth commit great whoredom, [departing] from Jehovah." — Hosea 1:2 (ASV)

The beginning of the word ...—More correctly, In the beginning when the Lord spoke to Hosea, the Lord said ...

Go, take to you a wife of whoredoms—How are we to interpret the prophet’s marriage to the licentious Gomer? Is it a historical occurrence, the only too real tragedy of the author’s personal experience, employed for the purpose of illustration? (Compare the domestic incident, Isaiah 8:1–4.) Or is this opening chapter merely an allegorical representation, designed to exhibit in vivid colours the terrible moral condition of Israel? (Compare the symbolic actions described in Jeremiah 25:15-29; Ezekiel 4:4–6; and perhaps Isaiah 20:1-3.)

Able writers have advocated each of these opposed theories; but in our opinion, the balance of evidence inclines to the former view, which regards the events as historical. The further question arises: Was Gomer guilty before or after the marriage?

The former supposition involves the harshness of conceiving such a marriage as the result of a Divine command, but the latter supposition admits of a satisfactory interpretation. The wickedness which after marriage revealed itself to the prophet’s agonised heart was transfigured to the inspired seer into an emblem of his nation’s wrong to Jehovah. In the light of this great idea, the prophet’s past came before him in a changed aspect.

As he reflected on the marvellous symbolic adaptation of this episode to the terrible spiritual needs of his fellow countrymen, which he was called by God to supply, the Divine purpose which shaped his sorrowful career became interpreted to his glowing consciousness as a Divine command—Go, take to yourself a wife of whoredoms. He had suffered acutely, but the agony was part of God’s arrangement, and the very love that was repeatedly outraged proves ultimately to have been suggested by a Divine prompting.

Children of whoredoms—Children of Hosea’s marriage. The whole result of his family history was included in this divinely ordered plan.