Charles Ellicott Commentary John 8:11

"And she said, No man, Lord. And Jesus said, Neither do I condemn thee: go thy way; from henceforth sin no more." — John 8:11 (ASV)

She said, No man, Lord.—She simply answers His question. There is no plea for forgiveness. There is no attempt at defence. We do not know what passed in her heart; we do not know what was written upon her countenance. We do not know whether the word “Lord” was simply the “Sir” of courtesy, or whether it contained something of the reverence of worship. He knew all.

Neither do I condemn thee: go, and sin no more.—Or, more exactly, and be no longer a sinner. There is no expression of forgiveness or peace as we find in other cases. (Luke 7:48.) He does not condemn her, for God sent not His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved (John 3:17).

His words must have come to her as words of mercy in contrast to the angry words of those who dragged her before Him. He does not condemn her, and yet by these words she must have been condemned more truly than by any words of accuser.

He does not condemn her; and yet the very words that bid her go are the condemnation of her sin. (Compare to John 5:14.) As in the case of the woman of Samaria (John 4:0), there is something in the tone and manner of dealing with this woman that goes beyond all words. As we read the narrative, the heart completes the picture, and we feel it preserves for us a real incident in our Lord’s ministry of mercy.

It is a mark of truthfulness that the narrative tells us no more. It does not have the completeness of an apocryphal story. We feel we would like to know more. She passed from His presence as her accusers had before.

What came afterwards to her and to them? Did she, in obedience to the words now heard, go forth to a new life, rising through penitence and faith to pardon, peace, purity? Did they who shrank from His presence now, so learn His words as to come to that Presence again, seeking not judgment on others, but pardon for themselves?

Over all the veil is drawn. We may not trace the history of lives known only to themselves and to God. However, the lessons are clear, and remain to condemn every human judgment of another’s sin, to condemn every sin in our own lives, and to declare to every sinner the forgiveness that does not condemn.