Expositor's Bible Commentary Commentary Luke 9:8

"and by some, that Elijah had appeared; and by others, that one of the old prophets was risen again." — Luke 9:8 (ASV)

“All that was going on” probably refers to the activities of both Jesus and the disciples on their mission. Herod heard about Jesus’ miracles and had his questions about him. The questions of Jesus’ identity and also of the reappearance of a dead prophet are reintroduced in vv.18–19. John the Baptist is naturally on Herod’s mind (and doubtless also on his conscience). Herod was not able to see Jesus (v.9) but had his curiosity satisfied when Pilate sent Jesus to him (23:8–11).

The fact that this miracle is in all four gospels indicates its importance.

Luke’s account is sparse and straightforward.