Scholars debate the meaning of Abner's question, "Whose is the land?" Some commentators believe he is acknowledging David's divine right to the kingdom as a way to flatter him. However, others argue it's a prideful boast, essentially asking, "Who but me has the power to give you this land?" This view, favored by Ellicott, aligns with Abner's haughty character and his goal of securing a high price for his allegiance.