Scripture Spot Logo

Verse of the Day

WEB

Author Spotlight

Loading featured author...

Report Issue

See a formatting issue or error?

Let us know →

He said to them, "Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?" They said to him, "No, we did not so much as hear whether there is a Holy Spirit."

Verse Takeaways

1

Gifts vs. Indwelling

Commentators widely agree that Paul's question was not about the saving, indwelling work of the Holy Spirit, which he assumed these men had as believers. Instead, he was asking if they had received the extraordinary, miraculous gifts of the Spirit (like speaking in tongues) that often accompanied conversion in the early church as a sign of God's power.

See 3 Verse Takeaways

Book Overview

Acts

Author

Audience

Composition

Teaching Highlights

Outline

+ 5 more

See Overview

Commentaries

7

Albert Barnes

Albert Barnes

On Acts 19:2

18th Century

Theologian

Have you received the Holy Ghost? Have you received the extraordinary effusions and miraculous influences of the Holy Ghost? Paul would no…

AT Robertson

AT Robertson

On Acts 19:2

Did ye receive the Holy Spirit when ye believed? (ε πνευμα αγιον ελαβετε πιστευσαντεσ?). This use of Π in a direct question occurs…

Charles Ellicott

Charles Ellicott

On Acts 19:2

19th Century

Bishop

Have you received the Holy Ghost since you believed?—Better, as connecting the two facts in the English as in the Greek, …

Premium

Go Ad-Free

Go ad-free and create your own bookmark library

Expositor's Bible Commentary

Expositor's Bible Commentary

On Acts 19:2

The question Paul put to the twelve, “Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed,” suggests two things: (1) that he assumed they were truly …

John Calvin

John Calvin

On Acts 19:2

16th Century

Theologian

Whether they had received the Holy Ghost. The end of the history shows that Paul does not speak in this place of the Spirit of regeneratio…

John Gill

John Gill

On Acts 19:2

17th Century

Pastor

He said to them, have you received the Holy Ghost
Meaning, not the special regenerating and sanctifying grace of the…

Subscriber

Join Our Newsletter

Get curated content & updates

Matthew Henry

Matthew Henry

On Acts 19:1–7

17th Century

Minister

Paul, at Ephesus, found some religious people who looked to Jesus as the Messiah. They had not been led to expect the miraculous powers of the Holy…