Scripture Spot Logo

Verse of the Day

WEB

Author Spotlight

Loading featured author...

Report Issue

See a formatting issue or error?

Let us know →

His disciples answered him, "From where will one be able to fill these men with bread here in a desert place?"

Verse Takeaways

1

A Realistic Lapse in Faith

Commentators are struck by the disciples' question, as it suggests they had forgotten the recent feeding of the 5,000. Scholars explain this isn't necessarily a sign of total amnesia but a realistic depiction of human frailty. Even after witnessing God's power, believers can revert to doubt when facing a new crisis. Their response highlights how easily we can focus on the problem at hand rather than on God's past faithfulness and present power.

See 3 Verse Takeaways

Book Overview

Mark

Author

Audience

Composition

Teaching Highlights

Outline

+ 5 more

See Overview

Commentaries

6

AT Robertson

AT Robertson

On Mark 8:4

Here (ωδε). Of all places, in this desert region in the mountains. The disciples feel as helpless as when the five thousand were f…

Charles Ellicott

Charles Ellicott

On Mark 8:4

19th Century

Bishop

Satisfy.—The verb is the same as the “filled” of Mark 7:27.

Here in the wilderness.—The word here, as in M…

Charles Spurgeon

Charles Spurgeon

On Mark 8:1–4

19th Century

Preacher

Why did they not ask their Master what he could do in such an emergency as that? After so much experience of his power as they had already had, it …

Premium

Go Ad-Free

Go ad-free and create your own bookmark library

Expositor's Bible Commentary

Expositor's Bible Commentary

On Mark 8:4

The disciples’ reply suggests they had completely forgotten the feeding of the five thousand. This is perhaps the strongest argument against the vi…

John Gill

John Gill

On Mark 8:4

17th Century

Pastor

And his disciples answered him
The Syriac version renders it, "say unto him"; and the Persic and Ethiopic, "said unt…

Matthew Henry

Matthew Henry

On Mark 8:1–10

17th Century

Minister

Our Lord Jesus encouraged the lowliest to come to him for life and grace. Christ knows and considers our constitution. The bounty of Christ is alwa…

Subscriber

Join Our Newsletter

Get curated content & updates